Google+ Mom to 2 Posh Lil Divas: The Dissolving Egg Shell & Bouncing Egg Experiment

Thursday, April 12, 2012

The Dissolving Egg Shell & Bouncing Egg Experiment


This egg experiment has been in the works for over a week!
(I may or may not have forgotten to blog about it)

By now, you know the Lil Divas enjoy experimenting
and I love nurturing their curiosity.


This experiment is simple, it involves a lot of observation
but the results are really to watch and the finale was lots of messy fun.

To start with, I talked to the Lil Divas about what they thought
would happen if we put some eggs in vinegar and some in water.

They have prior knowledge of the effects of vinegar based on previous experiments, so they immediately said the egg would dissolve.  I thought it was a good hypothesis considering our recent
vinegar based experiments with Peeps. So we set out to see if they were correct.

What You Need:
eggs
(we used raw eggs - 2 brown & 2 white)
vinegar
water
clear cups

What To Do:
1. Set up 4 clear cups. 
2. Put 1 egg into each cup.
3. Add vinegar to 1 of each cup containing a white & brown egg.
4. Add water to the other 2 cups.
*eggs should be covered completely by each liquid.
5. Observe

Start of Experiment/Day 1:
The Lil Divas observed bubbles in the vinegar eggs right away.
We talked about the bubbles being carbon dioxide -
I know they don't "get it" yet but they asked and I wanted to answer as simply as possible.


After only a few hours we could see that the vinegar was eating away at the shell of the brown egg. It was nice to observe it at this initial reaction stage because you could easily see where the shell was missing and where it was still on the egg. The Lil Divas found this fascinating. 


Day 2:

Day 3:



Day 5:


Day 7:



Now that we had our rubbery eggs, 
we had to test if they could bounce!


The first drop did indeed bounce!

Then the Oldest Diva decided to go higher & splat!


Of course the Littlest Diva followed her lead
(I think she was more interested in the splat than the bounce!)


Here's how they landed -

Of course the Lil Divas had to explore the mess.



It was a bit smelly but still pretty cool.
I'd like to try this again and compare hard boiled to raw eggs.

What egg experiments have you done?

Bern

21 comments:

  1. What a great experiment, kids of all ages could take something away from this.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love this, especially the two splats!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. the splats were by far their favorite part too :)

      Delete
  3. Add the shell-less eggs to corn syrup or honey (I think it takes a few days) and see what happens. After that add them to water and observe once more. That's how my 6th grade teacher taught us about diffusion and osmosis!
    -Vicky

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Vicky, I see a part 2 to this in our future! Thanks for sharing that! :)

      Delete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Bern, this is our eggsperiment. We enjoyed it so much that we are doing it again, right now. http://happiestmomontheblog.blogspot.com/2012/05/eggsperiment.html
    Sorry, I forgot to include the link.

    ReplyDelete
  6. That looks like so much fun! I will have to try it with my two!

    ReplyDelete
  7. After all of the Shell is gone try adding the vinegar eggs into a cup of very colored water. It makes them look like easter eggs! =] That's the real fun. It's even better if you start off with the corn syrup/honey suggestion from above. !

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for the idea! I can't wait to use this experiment with my elementary class!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I seem to remember this sort of "experiment" about getting a whole egg, shell and all, into a bottle. Not having ever tried it, I assume it goes like this:
    When the shell becomes soft from the vinegar bath, maybe before it goes completely translucent, remove the egg from the vinegar and gently push the egg into a somewhat wide neck bottle (one whose neck is still smaller the diameter of the egg, of course). You may have to slide a small diameter straw into the bottle neck at the same time, (to allow for the air inside the bottle to escape as the egg enters it), then fill the bottle with water and the shell should reharden. Voila', you now have an egg in a bottle (like a ship in a bottle)!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I remember seeing that in Anna and the King.....Jodi Foster version. I believe it was a hard boiled egg, and it had something to do with a lit match. I believe you drop the lit match into the bottle, put the boiled egg on top of the bottle and when the match goes out and the difference in the air inside the bottle sucks the egg in. *sorry if the why isn't quite right...lol

      Delete
  10. i love these little cute science experiments to do with the kids i baby sit!
    kate

    ReplyDelete
  11. I remember doing this in school. Try coating half of the egg with toothpaste before putting it in the vinegar. If I recall correctly, the toothpaste side doesn't dissolve.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Another way of getting an egg into a bottle is to peel a hard boiled egg and light a match, pop it into the bottle and quickly place the egg on top. The egg will be drawn into the bottle.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Replies
    1. Well, you're missing out, my 10 year olds were amazed. We did just one egg, but I was also amazed. Never would have thought it was possible.

      Delete
  14. You might tell them that carbon dioxide (CO2) is an acid and is in all sodas. The eggshell is basically calcium and is a base. When you put them together you get an acid base reaction. Since these are basically weak components the reaction isn't very strong but something like urine & bleach will create a much stronger reaction and should be avoided.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for explaining. So I can give my kids the info as to why.

      Delete
  15. My first thougt on reading this was to measure and add the same amount of liquid to each cup and to weigh the cups immediately and each day. Do cups with vinegar weigh less and if so why? I think the cups with vinegar will weigh less because they are giving off the carbon monoxide.

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for taking the time to visit Mom to 2 Posh Lil Divas! I hope you will stay awhile to explore all we have to offer!